Stealing signs – Part 3: How to prevent your signs from being stolen

Try to steal your own pitchers’ signs and then let him know if you succeed.

When you find out that somehow a team is getting your pitch signs, there are a number of things that can be done.  Which solution chosen depends on how they are getting the signs, who is giving them to the batter, and/or what level of baseball this involves.  Below are the various things teams can do to prevent their pitch signs from being stolen and passed to the batters.

Study your own pitchers and catchers. As stated in Part 1, the most likely way batters get the pitch is by watching the habits of the pitchers and catchers.  Because of this, each team should watch their pitchers and catchers carefully to see if they are tipping off their pitches.  Some bench guys seem to have a knack for noticing when and how opposing pitchers tipoff their pitches.  Have these guys watch your own pitchers and tap into their expertise.  They can do the same for their catchers to see if any adjustments need to be made. Some catchers may need to set up for location a little later.  This is standard procedure for major league catchers.  Most give the sign to the pitcher but wait until the pitcher’s delivery starts before moving to the wanted location.  They do this to not allow the offensive team time to tell the batter the location of the upcoming pitch.   Having bench guys watch for all this gives them something constructive to do during the game as well.  To see a previous post I wrote for catchers involving batters who peek at the signs, click HERE.

Mix up your signs.  Obviously, if the team on offense is picking up your signs, an easy way to fix that is to change your signs.  If you suspect that your signs are being stolen, call timeout and have the pitcher and catcher adjust their sequence of signs.  Frequently changing your sequences if you suspect something usually ends the threat pretty quickly.  A future post will be dedicated to showing popular options that are used for pitch calling.

Although effective, there is a danger to both player and coach if anyone gets hurt.

*Promote some distrust.  I placed an asterisk next to this one because there are some dangers involved that players and coaches need to be aware of.  This technique involves “crossing up” the batter.  By that, I mean the catcher puts down the sign for one pitch and the pitcher purposely throws a different pitch.  Usually it would work like this.  The catcher might put down two fingers to indicate a curveball.  The curveball sign is then flashed to the batter.  The pitcher then throws a hard inside fastball.  The purpose of this strategy is to get the batters to no longer trust the signs being flashed to them. You can imagine the surprise of a batter if a slow, breaking pitch on the outer half of the plate is expected and a hard inside fastball is what they actually get.  “Crossing up” the hitter like this makes him rethink about his desire to get the signs beforehand.  Now the dangerous side.  If a batter believes that a slow, breaking ball is coming on the outer part of the plate, he may lean over the plate a bit more on the pitch.  He may also not initially attempt to get out of the way of the inside pitch because he may assume the pitch will eventually break away from him.  Obviously, it won’t.  As a result, he may get hit with the pitch.  Most of the time if a batter gets hit, he won’t get hurt.  He learns the lesson and moves on.  However, there is always the threat that serious injury could occur especially if the pitch ends up near the head/face area.  That location of the pitch coupled with the fact that the hitter will not react like normal can create a big danger.  If it should come out later that a pitcher and catcher were told to use this strategy and it resulted in a serious injury, the coach may at the very least have to start looking for another coaching job.